How were Pullman Porters paid?
Frequently Asked Question about the extinct profession: Pullman Porter
Pay was a company wage by the month, kept low for decades on the theory that tips would finish it. Those tips were a large share of real income and a central grievance, because they varied by route, by season, and by the passenger. The 1937 contract raised the wage and did not make tips trivial. Nothing was paid by the berth made or the shoe shined.